Prosecutors are arguing Anthony D'Onofrio fatally shot Lexie Castile, while the defense is arguing she killed herself in West 24th Street apartment.

Erie lawyer Chad Vilushis, who is representing D'Onofrio, told the jury in his opening remarks that there is no question ...

The trial for the man accused of killing his 20-year-old fiance in 2012 continued. Anthony D’Onofrio is accused of killing ...

Lexie N. Castile, 20, was rushed to UPMC Hamot, but died of a gunshot wound to her head. Her fiancé, Anthony D'Onofrio, then 25, would tell a 911 operator that Castile shot herself in the head.